Building institutional capacity through inclusion, or the other way around? Implications of opening higher education to displaced students in Italy
- Cristina Mazzero, University of Trento (Italy)
Event Materials
This event is now archived and we are pleased to provide the following event media and assets, along with the original event overview.
In front of contemporary geopolitical challenges, European higher education institutions (HEISs) are increasingly called to take action for the global common goods (Marginson, 2018) and to align internationalization and third mission agendas (Jones et al., 2022). One significant step in this direction has been the inclusion of refugee and refugee-like students through the establishment of various University Provisions for Displaced Students (UPDSs). However, while recent research starts examining the impact of UPDSs on students’ educational careers (Bacher et al., 2020; Lambrechts, 2020), less is known about the extent to which – and how – the inclusion of this vulnerable category redefines HEIs mission, pedagogical strategies, and internal organization. To fill this gap, the paper explores how UPDSs transform HEIs institutional capacity and redesign their relationships with external actors at multiple scales (local, national, and international). The focus is on Italy, an understudied context where internationalization goals struggle with restrictive migration policies. Thus, it can provide interesting comparative insights with more extensively researched European countries. Drawing from a purposive sample of nine Italian universities, the paper triangulates documentary research and interview data to provide a first analytical typology of the different UPDSs implemented since 2015. The preliminary analysis shows that UPDSs significantly increase Italian HEIs engagement with government bodies, private sector, and NGOs at different scales. However, UPDSs management is frequently deputized to few, goodwilled employees as additional workload, and is marked by heavy bureaucratic constraints. This results in a general lack of transferability of institutional capacity not only between but also within universities, limiting these practices of inclusion to consolidate. The implications of this study suggest that for displaced students in Italy, access and inclusion into HEIs remain highly staggered and dependent on how UPDSs categorize and understand student displacement. For higher education policymaking, this study highlights the need to rethink the balance between accountability, equitable access and long-term sustainability of these programs.
Event Notes
Please find the General Privacy Policy of UCL, one of our partner universities, here: https://www.ucl.ac.uk/legal-services/privacy/general-privacy-notice
Share this event
Cristina Mazzero is a PhD Candidate in Sociology and Social Research at the University of Trento (Italy). She gained her MA in Sociology with a thesis on the intertwined experience of academic freedom and forced mobility of Belarusian student activists. Currently, her PhD research investigates the characteristics and implications of higher education policies addressing the inclusion of displaced students in Italian academia. Her main research interests concern, more broadly, forced migration in academic settings, international student mobility(ies), and academic freedom.
In 2023, Cristina was awarded the 1st prize in a Student Essay Competition by the OSUN Global Observatory on Academic Freedom, with an article on the conceptualization of student academic freedom. At present, she is co-authoring the book “Criminalizing Ideas: the Global Threats to Scholars and Students” (University of New Orleans Press, forthcoming 2025). Cristina is also a member of the Jean Monnet research project “ESAF – European Societies and Academic Freedom: Patterns, Problems, Solutions”.
