Building Halos: how do Chinese elites seek distinction through (mis) recognising studying abroad?
- Dr. Ye Liu, King’s College London, UK
- Dr. Wenqin Shen, Peking University, China
Event Materials
This event is now archived and we are pleased to provide the following event media and assets, along with the original event overview.
Why do Chinese elite graduates choose to study abroad? How do they construct “distinction”? Using a case study of Peking University and drawing upon empirical data from a first-hand survey study, in-depth interviews and observations, we find a pattern of distinction making through “building triple halos”, which encompasses dual processes of educational emulation and (mis-)recognition. Our statistical analyses suggest that students from leading cadres and managerial families actively pursued study abroad as “extra time” to make distinction, which games out even elite graduates without adequate economic resources. The qualitative data reveal a complex process of distinction-making which connects individual agency and educational processes with organisational intermediaries. The elites signal superiority by building three “halos” (elite schools, PKU and the Ivy League scholarship-holders)-a process gradually narrowing the circle of “us” and excluding aspirational “others”. This individual level of distinction-making is coordinated with collective consensus, and organisational intermediaries in seeking, justifying, and (mis-)recognising studying abroad as a pathway to distinction. We further reveal the complexity of the identities of the PKU elites as both possessors and challengers of distinction. Yet, the main beneficiaries are the agents of the study-abroad industry, who not only consolidate their client base in PKU but also pursue a new business route of accommodating the challengers. This particular finding will be discussed in relation to China’s recent crackdown on the study abroad industry.
CGHE webinars are fully open to participants. They are interactive, enabling attendees to speak directly in the webinar, ask questions of speakers when called in by the chair and see all other participants. At any time you can communicate directly with others, either all together or on a one-to-one basis, through the webinar Chat.
Share this event
LIU Ye is a Senior Lecturer at the Department of International Development, King’s College London. Her research focuses on education, gender, social trust, and the legacies of China’s one-child policy. She is currently writing a book manuscript about siblingless urban women from the one-child generation and on how patriarchy still holds those women back during their life course transitions to the labour market, marriage and motherhood. She is also the author of Higher Education, Meritocracy and Inequality in China (Springer 2016).
SHEN Wenqin is Associate Professor of Higher Education at Peking University. His research focuses on the higher education system from the perspectives of history and science studies (Sociology of Science, philosophy of science, etc). He authored and co-authored publications on transnational history of idea and practice of liberal education (China, UK and US), international academic mobility (especially the mobility of doctoral students and postdocs) and doctoral career trajectories.
